Fitzy's Cafe Menu

Welcome to Fitzy's Cafe, a cozy gem nestled in Whitefish Bay, WI. This welcoming spot serves up a delightful menu crafted for both casual diners and discerning palates. Patrons can indulge in an array of refreshing beverages, including robust brewed teas like the English Breakfast and the exotic Dragon Well. Seasonal specialties like Pumpkin Chai and Peach Cobbler Latte elevate the drink offerings, while the pastries, including the zesty Citrus Olive Oil Cake and the intriguing Yuzu Black Sesame Tart, are perfect complements to your morning coffee.

Beyond the delightful drinks and baked goods, customers rave about the bold flavors found in the sandwiches. The ambiance strikes a harmonious balance between relaxed and sophisticated, making it an ideal spot for both casual catch-ups and intimate lunch dates. Fitzy's Cafe seamlessly blends taste and atmosphere, ensuring a satisfying experience with every visit.

Beverages - Brewed Coffee

• Brewed Coffee

• Cafe Au Lait

  1/2 Brewed Coffee, 1/2 Steamed Milk

• Cold Brew

• Pour Over

  US$5.00

• 96oz Box Of Coffee

  US$25.00

Beverages - Espresso

• Affogato

  Double shot of espresso paired with a scoop of Scratch or Purple Door ice cream

  US$7.00

• Americano

  Espresso and water

• Cappuccino

  Espresso, steamed milk, and a heavy layer of foam

• Cortado

  Double shot of espresso and equal parts steamed milk

  US$4.00

• Espresso

  Fitzy's House Blend Espresso roasted by Metric Coffee

  US$3.50

• Macchiato

  Espresso with a light dollop of milk foam

  US$4.00

• Mocha

  Espresso paired with rich Indulgence Chocolate and steamed milk

• Latte

  Espresso and steamed milk with a smooth layer of milk foam

Beverages - Specialty Drinks

• The Fitz

  Espresso, Choice of milk, Maple, Palo Santo Bitters, Lemon Fennel Salt

Beverages - Brewed Tea

• English Breakfast, 12 Oz.

  Organic Black, High Caffeine. Malty and robust, with sweet, chocolatey undertones

  US$5.00

• Silencio, 12 Oz.

  Spicy Black, High Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Ripe Pineapple, Black Pepper, Cocoa Bean

  US$5.00

• Black Metallic, 12 Oz.

  Black, High Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Candied Violet, Elderberry, Blackberry, Incense

  US$5.00

• Dragon Well, 12 Oz.

  Organic Green, Low Caffeine. Traditional pan-roasted green tea with a pleasant roasted chestnut flavor and low tannin

  US$5.00

• Jasmine Green, 12 Oz.

  US$5.00

• Mojave, 12 Oz.

  Herbal Smoky Hibiscus Cherry Tea, Low Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Black Cherry, Hibiscus, Mezcal

  US$5.00

• Bergamot Rose, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Rooibos, Hibiscus, Maqui Berry, Schisandra Berry, Murta Berry, Rose Petals, Bergamot, Lavender, Tulsi

  US$5.00

• Blueberry Rooibos, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Rooibos, Elderberry, Hibiscus Flowers, Currants, Blueberry, Schisandra Berry, Strawberry

  US$5.00

• Days Of Heaven, 12 Oz.

  Organic Herbal Rhubarb Lemon Verbena and Chamomile, Caffeine-Free. Flavor Notes: Rhubarb Jam, Custard, California Sagebrush, Pie Crust

  US$5.00

• Mystic Mint, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Peppermint, Cardamom, Licorice Root, Basil, and Clove Leaf

  US$5.00

• Turmeric Ginger, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Turmeric, Ginger, Licorice Root, Lemongrass, Orange, Lemon

  US$5.00

• Cinnamon Plum

  US$5.00

Beverages - Not Coffee

• Chai Tea Latte

• Hot Chocolate

• Iced Tea

• Kyoto Fog

  Hojicha tea, house-made Konbu dashi syrup, milk

• Lemonade

  US$4.00

• Matcha Latte

  Ceremonial matcha, house-made konbu dashi syrup, milk

• Milk

• Steamer

Beverages - Seasonal

• Pumpkin Chai

• Peach Cobbler Latte

• Caramel Apple Latte

Brewed Coffee

• Brewed Coffee

• Cafe Au Lait

  1/2 Brewed Coffee, 1/2 Steamed Milk

• Cold Brew

• Pour Over

  US$5.00

• 96oz Box Of Coffee

  US$25.00

Espresso

• Affogato

  Double shot of espresso paired with a scoop of Scratch or Purple Door ice cream

  US$7.00

• Americano

  Espresso and water

• Cappuccino

  Espresso, steamed milk, and a heavy layer of foam

• Cortado

  Double shot of espresso and equal parts steamed milk

  US$4.00

• Espresso

  Fitzy's House Blend Espresso roasted by Metric Coffee

  US$3.50

• Macchiato

  Espresso with a light dollop of milk foam

  US$4.00

• Mocha

  Espresso paired with rich Indulgence Chocolate and steamed milk

• Latte

  Espresso and steamed milk with a smooth layer of milk foam

Specialty Drinks

• The Fitz

  Espresso, Choice of milk, Maple, Palo Santo Bitters, Lemon Fennel Salt

Brewed Tea

• English Breakfast, 12 Oz.

  Organic Black, High Caffeine. Malty and robust, with sweet, chocolatey undertones

  US$5.00

• Silencio, 12 Oz.

  Spicy Black, High Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Ripe Pineapple, Black Pepper, Cocoa Bean

  US$5.00

• Black Metallic, 12 Oz.

  Black, High Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Candied Violet, Elderberry, Blackberry, Incense

  US$5.00

• Dragon Well, 12 Oz.

  Organic Green, Low Caffeine. Traditional pan-roasted green tea with a pleasant roasted chestnut flavor and low tannin

  US$5.00

• Jasmine Green, 12 Oz.

  US$5.00

• Mojave, 12 Oz.

  Herbal Smoky Hibiscus Cherry Tea, Low Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Black Cherry, Hibiscus, Mezcal

  US$5.00

• Bergamot Rose, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Rooibos, Hibiscus, Maqui Berry, Schisandra Berry, Murta Berry, Rose Petals, Bergamot, Lavender, Tulsi

  US$5.00

• Blueberry Rooibos, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Rooibos, Elderberry, Hibiscus Flowers, Currants, Blueberry, Schisandra Berry, Strawberry

  US$5.00

• Days Of Heaven, 12 Oz.

  Organic Herbal Rhubarb Lemon Verbena and Chamomile, Caffeine-Free. Flavor Notes: Rhubarb Jam, Custard, California Sagebrush, Pie Crust

  US$5.00

• Mystic Mint, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Peppermint, Cardamom, Licorice Root, Basil, and Clove Leaf

  US$5.00

• Turmeric Ginger, 12 Oz.

  Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Turmeric, Ginger, Licorice Root, Lemongrass, Orange, Lemon

  US$5.00

• Cinnamon Plum

  US$5.00

Not Coffee

• Chai Tea Latte

• Hot Chocolate

• Iced Tea

• Kyoto Fog

  Hojicha tea, house-made Konbu dashi syrup, milk

• Lemonade

  US$4.00

• Matcha Latte

  Ceremonial matcha, house-made konbu dashi syrup, milk

• Milk

• Steamer

Seasonal

• Pumpkin Chai

• Peach Cobbler Latte

• Caramel Apple Latte

Bakery - Pastries

• Citrus Olive Oil Cake

  US$8.00

• Yuzu Black Sesame Tart

  US$8.50

Bakery - Croissants

• Almond Croissant

  Almond Coix with Orange Blossom from Novel Tea & Bakery

  US$6.00

• Butter Croissant

  Butter Croix from Novel Tea & Bakery

  US$5.00

• Chocolate & Guava Croissant

  US$6.00

Bakery - Cookies

• Chocolate Chunk Cookie

  Huge Chocolate Chunk Cookie

  US$5.00

• Brown Butter Miso Cookie

  US$5.50

Bakery - Confectionery

• Dubai Chocolate - Singular

  US$1.99

• Dubai Date - Singular

  US$1.99

• Assorted Chocolate - Singular

  US$0.99

Bakery - Dubai Bar

• Milk

  US$19.99

• Dark

  US$19.99

Bakery - Indulgence Dubai

• Dark

  US$25.00

• Milk

  US$25.00

Pastries

• Citrus Olive Oil Cake

  US$8.00

• Yuzu Black Sesame Tart

  US$8.50

Croissants

• Almond Croissant

  Almond Coix with Orange Blossom from Novel Tea & Bakery

  US$6.00

• Butter Croissant

  Butter Croix from Novel Tea & Bakery

  US$5.00

• Chocolate & Guava Croissant

  US$6.00

Cookies

• Chocolate Chunk Cookie

  Huge Chocolate Chunk Cookie

  US$5.00

• Brown Butter Miso Cookie

  US$5.50

Confectionery

• Dubai Chocolate - Singular

  US$1.99

• Dubai Date - Singular

  US$1.99

• Assorted Chocolate - Singular

  US$0.99

Dubai Bar

• Milk

  US$19.99

• Dark

  US$19.99

Indulgence Dubai

• Dark

  US$25.00

• Milk

  US$25.00

Ice Cream - Ice Cream

• Single Scoop

• Double Scoop

Ice Cream

• Single Scoop

• Double Scoop

Milkshakes - Milkshakes

• Milkshake

  US$7.00

• Custom Milkshake

  US$7.00

Milkshakes

• Milkshake

  US$7.00

• Custom Milkshake

  US$7.00

Free Coffee Promotion - Free Cup of Coffee Coupon

• Free Cup Of Coffee

  US$0.00

Free Cup of Coffee Coupon

• Free Cup Of Coffee

  US$0.00